Ryan Giggs is not having a great season and I have been surprised somewhat at how easily he has kept his starting place in the team. With Nani emerging as a good winger, I’d have liked to see him rewarded with more time on the field this season. He is lacking in several departments, that is to be expected, but he can only improve with minutes on the pitch. At such a young age, of course he has plenty of time for that ahead of him, but his competition for Giggs’ place compliments Ryan, with Nani seemingly deserving a starting place more often than he’s been given credit for.
What Giggs is now lacking in pace he can make up for in experience, but generally, Giggs has looked pretty lazy and unmotivated on too many occasions this season. This isn’t me having a dig at him, as he is a much loved player, and has contributed massively to our success, recently, and in years gone by. But I can’t help but feel his performances would improve if he felt as though he had more pressure on him. He has had truly poor games, but has managed to see out the ninety minutes, and is straight in the first XI the following game.
Some may argue Ferguson is eager to give Giggs the opportunity to beat Sir Bobby Charlton’s appearances, and with him turning thirty four next week, time is not on his side. I’m all for that. Nobody deserves a place in our history books more than Ryan Giggs at present, but this shouldn’t be to the exclusion of players deserving of a match.
However, in our recent victory over Blackburn Rovers, Giggsy played a blinder, following a rare omission from the team when Ferguson trusted our young players to see us through to the next round of Europe against Dynamo Kiev. It was his perfectly weighted and placed corner from which Ronaldo scored our first goal, breaking the deadlock in a game when we’d already seen one Blackburn attempt come back off the woodwork. He played some great football and showed off some silky skills we haven’t seen in some time (6 mins 23 on the video), and was unfortunate to be floored by the Blackburn defence after making mugs of them with his quick feet just outside the area. He saw out the ninety minutes, and fully deserved to do so.
Surely dropping Giggs more often would be the perfect way to ignite that hunger and passion he seems to be lacking at times? No player should feel as though his place in the team is safe, but it appears that’s exactly how it is for Giggs.
However, he has today said that he does feel the pressure, and that every day at training is a test for him against our crop of young players. “When you come into training and you’re up against young, quality players it’s a test every day,” he said. “That only helps to bring your game on. There’s so much enthusiasm amongst the lads and it’s a great place to be at the moment. They’re all very enthusiastic and the team spirit is as good as ever.”
Giggsy has still got it, that I am not denying, but I think the only way we can really see the full benefit of our new signings is if they are given more time on the park. Not only will this improve their game, but it will improve the game of our older players. Nani, Anderson and Simpson should all be giving Giggs, Scholes and Neville a run for their money, and making them feel as though they have to work harder than ever to keep their place in the team.
So come on Fergie, give Nani a go, and watch Giggs go from strength to strength!
What do you think? Should Nani and Ronaldo be given more time to terrorise our opposition down the wings? Or does Giggs deserve to play because of his legendary status at the club?
Man Utd News 24/7
Scott, you are spot on!!! I feel that Nani, Anderson and Simpson have to be given more chances. Giggs has to be given more breaks and be occasionally used just like Maldini is used by AC Milan.
Presently Anderson is a big match player according to Fergie (as he said he would have played against Kiev if it was important).
In the away match to Roma, and the home match with sporting I would like to see Simpson, Pique given the chance. Especially in the away game with the likes of Totti and Guily bombarding it would be a good experience for the youngsters to learn a thing or two against such quality opposition.
Scott, what do you think about the Veloso rumours? He is a good player but unless we are thinking of getting rid of O’Shea I dont see where he will fit in. Also what does that mean to the home grown talent Darren Gibson?
In defence with Cathcart waiting in the wings.. . Vidic, Ferdinand and Brown not old.. I get a feeling that one of Pique or Evans might be sold
Scott, could you in one of your posts write about how good the next generation Reds are…
Cathcart, Macheda, Danny Welbeck, Sam Hewson, Brandao, Brandy, Eikrem. How do you rate these guys.. does anyone of these have the talent to take the world like Giggsy, Scholesy or Becks?
And how about the championship player of the month Shawcross?
go to hospital check your brain
Giggs is way better than Nani. Nani loses the ball too often, puts the defence under pressure, and dives and whinges too much at the moment. He should be used sparingly as a sub.
Scott. I have been a great fan of your posts. But this post of yours has really put me off. Nani is still not good enough to replace Giggsy. Nani seems very confused with the ball at his feet and he loses the ball often at the wrong places. Moreover, Nani lacks Giggsy’s intelligence and positioning. He needs atleast a season more to demand a position in the starting 11. Nani is only a backup for Giggs and could be used against weaker oppositions. Giggs is a genius and his experience is vital for the big games. His brilliant outside-of-the-foot cross to Tevez against Chelsea and a sexy lob to Rooney against Arsenal are reasons why Giggs is as valuable as Rooney or Ronaldo. His display against Blackburn was so pleasing to watch and I am sure there will be many more moments like that in matches to come.
GIGGS IS GOD
You’re right. Ryan Giggs is God – Nani should be learning from him this season. I believe Ferguson will hand a chance to Nani to test himself against the likes of Roma and Sporting with us already being through to the knock-out stages. However I still think that Ferguson will prefer to start with Giggs in the big games to give defences a thorough workout before unleashing Nani late on to finish off the tired legs.
I believe that Giggs and Scholes are the biggest big-match players we have at the moment because of their experience and love of the club.
dont put rooney and ronaldo in the same sentence.ronalfo is world class for real.i will explain why.who are the contenters for world player of the year and who do you think deserves it?where is rooney on that list? great player but not in the class of ronaldo
Ronaldo was better than Rooney last season. This season Rooney is playing as good as Ronaldo, if not better. Also, last season, it was Rooney who made his presence felt in big games (Milan, Roma, Arsenal). Both are equally gifted and equally important. And as far as the contenders’ list, my choice is Ronaldo, even though, (going by media reports) it looks like Kaka will pip him for the award.
Maybe I’m alone, but I see the point of this post as less of a declaration of Nani being better than Giggs, and more of a comment on Giggs performance and asking what motivates him. The glint of old Giggsy we saw in the Blackburn match was unlike anything we’ve seen since the beginning of last season. Why was that? Where did the sudden flash of Giggs glory days come from? It happened to coincide with the same match in which he didn’t start. I love Giggsy with my whole heart, and seeing him shine against the rovers… I want that back for him. I want him to be able to play out the end of his career with that brilliance. And maybe.. that means not starting him sometimes to get that fire going. IMO
yes, considering nani’s brilliant performance in Rome, fergie should give more oppotunity to nani.especially giggs’s age do not allow him to keep his 100% energy and attention in the pitch.
the youngers need more chance to show their genius. Don’t get me wrong, i do not want to have a dig at Giggs and deny his contribution . i also admit that there is a far cry between them , but i don’t think this matters. if Fergie is willing , i think, to give them equal competition , MU will benifit and we will see a more jewelly red devil.