rss twitter facebook mobile

Minute’s Applause? Sod off!

Of all the teams we had to play when remember the Munich Air Disaster, it doesn’t get a lot worse than the bitters. Liverpool would be worse, as they, unlike City, have no reason to hold back on their sick Munich chants. As City had to be reminded in a letter from their manager that accompanied the tickets, City’s own legend Frank Swift lost his life in the crash.

There had been talk of honouring the Babes with a minute’s applause, instead of a more appropriate minute’s silence, to drawn out any of the songs the away support might sing. I feared that instead of exposing the scum bags for what they are in front of the eyes of the world, United would cave and forgo the silence.

Kevin Parker, the City supporters’ club secretary, has admitted today that they were desperate for an applause to be given, so the club could escape the humiliation of their sick fans’ chants. “Although there is some friendly rivalry between supporters of the two clubs, there is also a great deal of hatred and there will be some City fans who will not want to go along with the recognition of the disaster,” he said. “We plead with United to change the proposed minute’s silence to applause. In this way, any idiot who does not share these views (of respect) will be drowned out rather than highlighted.”

So, United should not honour our dead heroes in the way we feel fit, just to save City’s blushes? If the minority of City fans want to show up the rest of them, and their club, then so be it. That is not our problem.

In response, it has been announced today that the more respectful minute’s silence will rightly go ahead. United’s communications director Phil Townsend told the club’s official website: “Manchester United have given great thought to the best way of remembering those who died at Munich. We feel a minute’s silence is the most appropriate way of paying tribute. We do not feel that applause is appropriate given that 23 people died.”

Will the City fans surprise us and respect the occasion?

About Scott

Scott is the editor of Red Matters - 50 Years of Supporting Manchester United and an author of Play Like Fergie's Boys and Not Nineteen Forever. He writes for ESPN, The Metro and Bleacher Report. Follow @R_o_M on Twitter.

View all posts by Scott »



  1. jsos says:

    will they surprise us? i think the majority will… but there’s always going to be an idiot in the bunch. the real surprise will be if city’s OWN fans do the reprimanding of the inevitable bell end who decides to open their mouth. THAT would be the best surprise.

  2. Tom F says:

    If your question is: Will 100% of Manchester City fans suprise us and show respect to the silence and not go out of their way to TRY to ruin the proceedings, then my answer is: NO.

  3. Kfoeva says:

    Who knows, they might just.

  4. Ingar says:

    No way, Bertie from Stockport is a proof that Darwin was right about evolution. And why the hell should we applaud a plane crash that took 23 lives and gave the survivors mental scars? Come on.

    Another thing that annoys me, is when people/journalists/whatever say/write “a team that was cut down in its prime”. No they weren’t! The average age of the team that won the league in the 55/56 season was just 22. All the more astonishing. The Babes should’ve dominated club football for at least a decade.


You must be logged in to post a comment.