Comments on: VIDEO: United Target Keeper Manuel Neuer In Action

By: dazbowski

dazbowski — Fri, 14 Aug 2009 16:34:31 +0000

oh rossee, what an intelligent statement, not only are you racist and can’t spell, you’ve clearly no idea what your talking about!

By: shakshamboo

shakshamboo — Fri, 14 Aug 2009 15:20:34 +0000

From this video i have concluded that
On a scale of 1 to 10
(error consideration= +-1)

Foster:

Reflexes=8
Anticipation=7
Positioning=7
Handling=8
Aerial Ability=8
Kicking=8
Throwing=8

Neuer:

Reflexes=9
Anticipation=9
Positioning=9
Handling=8
Aerial Ability=?
Kicking=?
Throwing=?

What do u guys think?

By: manutd4eve

manutd4eve — Fri, 14 Aug 2009 13:27:44 +0000

i do follow bundes liga games very closely for some reasons. yes this guy was very impressive last season. just only 23 and imagine when he comes to foster’s age. foster is a gud goalie and i want an english keeper to do the job for my mighty united but not convinced in foster. surely manutd signing him in january for sure. most of the big clubs not interested in him coz they all got good ones at the same time he dont want to b in the bench as he is a main candidate for german. sign him up fergie. lets give some chance to foster untill VDS recover then decide whether we want this guy or not.

By: Micky

Micky — Fri, 14 Aug 2009 11:02:11 +0000

@schmikes1

My point was the guy above watched ONE edited video of him and said ‘he looks worth the money’.

I’ll be honest, I’ve never heard of him. I’ve never seen him play. All I’ve ever seen of the lad is that video and he looks amazing. But should I go to YouTube and find a video that makes Taibi look like The Great Dane to prove my point?

He could be gash. The same game he made one amazing save, he might have let someone meg him from 80 yards for all we know. He might be fantastic and he might be a snip at £5m, but we can’t tell that from one video surely?

Is there anyone on here that has seen him quite a bit?

By: ash

ash — Fri, 14 Aug 2009 10:20:16 +0000

the season hasnt started and we want foster out of the team. cmon guys ben has hardly played for united. when alex give the likes of carrol a season to perform y not foster. for me he is the number 1 keeper for both england and united.but this german lad looks great. wont mind if he comes to united.

By: Dave Mack

Dave Mack — Fri, 14 Aug 2009 00:37:41 +0000

Highlights video like this don’t tell you anything. Just about every keeper in just about any league could put something equally impressive together over a season. What I’d want to see is how he handles crosses and corners. Does he control his six yard box? And most important is he two footed and how accrute is his kicking and throwing? The sort of keeper I love to see is one you’d fancy as having a chance of holding his place as a central defender, at least in the reserves. (A bit of an exageration …. but you know what I mean!!)

By: 20legend99

20legend99 — Thu, 13 Aug 2009 23:00:53 +0000

He really is Schmeichel-esque. All indicators point to Foster not being a top choice keeper, and we only have one more year tops out of VDS. This kid looks class, I really hope we get him. Remember how hard it was to get another good keeper after Schmeichel? Let’s not go through that again.

By: kel

kel — Thu, 13 Aug 2009 21:03:02 +0000

Seriously speaking, Neuer reminds me of Schmeichel too. I been mentioning foster save most with his foot and his hand is not as strong as foot. As for kicking, he is not very comfortable as mention by some post and i agree with it, he is anxious and not confident on the ball and that is really a bad thing consider that is the most basic thing. Of course i do like him to continue in our club but hope he really can step up if not, i really losing faith in him. Neuer looks kind of good and if reports is true, Sir Alex will have send scouts to see him in action and was impress. Not by youtube standard. Another point i want to make is in the defensive midfield area, i agree with those who said that is the area we need to improve. I do hope Hargreaves come back if not we need another. Gibson is not defensive midfielder. Possebon is load out and Petrucci not even start regularly. We seriously need another defensive midfielder if we were to win the champions league this season.

By: rossee

rossee — Thu, 13 Aug 2009 20:54:07 +0000

FOSTER IS A KLUTZ, KUZACK IS BOLLOX….FERGIE GO GET THAT KRAUT ….LOOKS LIKE THE NEXT SCHMEICHAL…….

By: Cavalry

Cavalry — Thu, 13 Aug 2009 18:23:35 +0000

He has that kind of form at 23? Assuming he doesn’t peak early, we could be set for a decade with this kid.