rss twitter facebook mobile

Vote For Our Player Of The Season

The Daily Mail are looking at who has been each clubs’ player of the season so far, with Edwin Van der Sar, Nemanja Vidic and Ryan Giggs making their shortlist. Who do you reckon deserves it?

About Scott

Scott is the editor of Red Matters - 50 Years of Supporting Manchester United and an author of Play Like Fergie's Boys and Not Nineteen Forever. He writes for ESPN, The Metro and Bleacher Report. Follow @R_o_M on Twitter.

View all posts by Scott »



  1. Roman says:

    Vida, for the whole season he is not just the best on his position (year I’m not talking about Liverpool game) he also was doing half of Rio’s work.
    My list is:
    1. Vidic
    2. Rooney
    3. Giggs

  2. Anastasia74 says:

    Nemanja Vidic

  3. North Stand,Tier 3,Back Row says:


  4. Ella says:

    Best player: Vidic

    Best young player: Johnny Evans

  5. costas says:

    I think Rooney has had his most effective season for us when it comes to goals per games ratio.But Rooney has started about 28 games.Nemanja has been the best throughout the season.Hopefully he will put the Liverpool game behind him.

  6. birchy says:

    1. Ryan Giggs
    2. Nemanja Vidic
    3. Michael Carrick

    Young Players

    1. Jonny Evans
    2. Rapheal Da Dilva
    3. Danny Welbeck

    name another top club that can have brought through 3 youngsters aswel as those 3 have played this season?

  7. ashwin says:

    if we dont win the epl from this position none deserves it really

  8. SULLY says:

    Nemanja Vidic

  9. Myq says:


  10. United forever-henry says:

    For me really, Vidic has been d most consistent player in all sense,performance likewise, excellent. And i do believe he’ll put d liverpool blip behind & continue wth d excellent consistent performances he has been putting in before d scoucers incident. United we stand… United FOREVER!

  11. n667 says:

    Fletcher after vida ofcourse!

  12. DinoTheDog says:

    My vote goes to Vidic.

  13. Ben says:

    Player of the Season:
    1. Vidic
    2. Giggs
    3. Carrick
    4. Fletcher
    5. Park

    Young Player of the Season:
    1. Evans
    2. Rafael
    3. Danny Welbeck
    4. Darron Gibson
    5. Nani

  14. stretford end says:

    The hitman vidic

  15. Nicky says:

    Nemanja Vidic

  16. Tom F says:

    Ryan Giggs



  17. five says:

    Vidic…a collosus at the back.

    Gotta give props to Fletcher(who thought 2 years back that we’d talk about him as one of our players of the season?) and Carrick.


You must be logged in to post a comment.