Republik Of Mancunia: A Manchester United Blog
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Archives
  • Contact
    • Advertise
  • Live
  • About
    • Privacy
  • App
  • Shop
  1. Home
  2. Manchester United News

POLL: Scapegoat award

  • December 31, 2010


Scott Patterson

Scott is the editor of RoM and has a season ticket at Old Trafford. He writes for The Mirror and Red News. He started The Republik of Mancunia in March 2006. Follow @R_o_M on Twitter.

RoM 2010 Awards: Scapegoat award
RoM 2010 Awards: Biggest Disappointment award

10 Comments

nosferatu December 31, 2010
Jonny Evans has been so disappointing since the summer (at least). Here I was thinking he could kick on and become a proper competitor for a centre back spot. Here's hoping Smalling learns from Evans's lesson: you've not made it until you've made it. Also hoping Evans can somehow turn it around and become the class act he is surely capable of being.
  • Log in to Reply
parjo December 31, 2010
I vote for Carrick, he's older and experient other than 2 others, he should have less bad performances.
  • Log in to Reply
loughie21 - TPL December 31, 2010
There's no other option but I'm voting for Bebe. Bebe was scapegoated at the start of the season as all that was wrong with 2010 United. We weren't good enough to win the league because we were buying players like Bebe. We didn't get Van Der Vaart/Ozil/Pele/Maradona because of Bebe. The stone cole proof we're in decline Bebe. Look at Chelsea score a hundred thousand goals against the worst of the league and United's only answer, Bebe. Did I mention he used to be homeless??

Thas all I heard for months. Now since then Bebe has played some matches, some good, some really bad but he's a young developing player just like dozens we've signed in the past. But he more than anyone was singled out and I think thats wrong.
  • Log in to Reply
loughie21 - TPL December 31, 2010
As an aside, I voted for Carrick. The other two have played really badly at times, Carrick has always been underrated and een when he played average fans got on his back more than say Rooney, Giggs, Scholes etc. when they had bad games
  • Log in to Reply
MyCowIsTheBest December 31, 2010
i would vote for John OShea.
  • Log in to Reply
sw December 31, 2010
I voted for carrick because he has been consistently underrated since he joined the club. In saying that he was truely awful last season. it is good to see him coming back to form. Evans could have got the nod too because he actually played quite well last season. I dont know whats happened to him. Gibson has been consistently poor since day one. im not sure what fergie sees in him. slow, one dimensional. we tend to get bad results whenever he plays.
  • Log in to Reply
smartalex December 31, 2010
loughie21 - TPL
Right, Bebe is ScapeKid 2010. Very unfairly shredded by the ABU press.

parjo
If you feel that Carrick has deserved his criticism, the Scapegoat Award is not for him.
  • Log in to Reply
BerbaGod December 31, 2010
How can it be Carrick? He has had a good season so far, all in all, and a mayor reason we are almost unbreakable at the moment.
The other two have maybe had 1 good game.
  • Log in to Reply
TheRadLegion December 31, 2010
Where PJS?
  • Log in to Reply
StatesideAussie December 31, 2010
I don't understand some of the comments here. Or maybe I don't understand the purpose of the award. This is for the 'scapegoat' of the year, not the worst player of the year, nor the most disappointing. A scapegoat is someone who's blamed for mistakes that others made -- or, loosely, someone who is unfairly blamed for some problem. I think O'Shea or Bebe would be excellent candidates for this award. Both are frequently, and in my opinion, unfairly criticized by fans as examples of what's "wrong" with United; in particular, O'Shea is often blamed for poor games that we have had, and for not being a better player; yet he's never held himself up to be anything more than what he is -- a versatile professional who's able and (most importantly) willing to do his bit as a stand-in squad player. Holding him responsible for some of our poor performances is simply pathetic, IMO.

Of the three who are on the list, I would go for Evans, who has copped more than his fair share of stick for some of our defensive lapses.
  • Log in to Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Log in with your Facebook or Twitter account:
Facebook Google Twitter
As featured on NewsNow: Manchester United newsMan Utd News 24/7

Categories

Recommended Sites

  • Football Blog
  • Kissed The Badge
  • Manchester United t-shirts
  • Red Matters
  • Red Rants
  • SportsHabit
  • Sportslens




Related Posts

amazon pt

RoM’s Manchester United 2017-18 season preview

  • July 21, 2017

CONFIRMED LINE-UP: Chelsea vs United

  • February 28, 2021

Man Utd 3-1 Newcastle: 3 Points In The Bag vs the Magpies

  • February 21, 2021

CONFIRMED LINE-UP: Real Sociedad vs United – Amad and Shoretire on the bench!

  • February 18, 2021
Front cover small

RoM’s Manchester United 2016-17 season preview

  • July 29, 2016

Rashford: Celebrating with Henderson is what I remember most about debut goal

  • February 25, 2021

CONFIRMED LINE-UP: United vs Newcastle – Shoretire on the bench!

  • February 21, 2021

Ole: I’ve included Amad and Shoretire to make an impact

  • February 17, 2021
_117335030_jameskovacic_getty

Chelsea 0-0 Man Utd: More Big Game Hum Drum

  • February 28, 2021

CONFIRMED LINE-UP: United vs Real Sociedad – captain Bruno!

  • February 25, 2021

Daniel James – the player United fans are rooting for

  • February 19, 2021
×Close